There is no single climate risk methodology, and the search for one misses the point. Financial institutions face two fundamentally different problems—physical damage from hazards and financial losses from the shift to a low-carbon economy—and each demands its own data, models, and institutional capabilities. The Bank for International Settlements observed in its April 2021 review of measurement methodologies that work to date has centered on mapping near-term transition risk drivers into bank exposures, with credit risk attracting the most effort, while physical risk analysis has typically been confined to selected hazards. Understanding where these approaches converge and diverge is the first step toward a defensible implementation plan.
Understanding Climate-Related Financial Risks
Climate risk reaches a bank or investor's balance sheet through two channels. Physical risks arise from acute events such as floods and storms and from chronic shifts in climate conditions. Transition risks arise from the move toward a lower-carbon economy: policy changes, technological advancement, market shifts, and reputational pressure. The Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions in Canada, in its climate risk management guidance, treats both as drivers that transmit into traditional risk categories—credit, market, and operational risk.
The critical point for methodology selection is that these two risk types cannot be measured with the same toolkit. A Council on Economic Policies report on integrating climate risks into credit risk analysis is explicit on this: the methodologies to assess them differ for physical and transition risks, and it describes them separately. Institutions that try to bolt a single model onto both tend to produce analysis that is credible for one and superficial for the other.





